Em & Me Studio vs Shiloh’s House (2026): Acrylic Pet Tags Compared
Choose Em & Me Studio if you want a handmade, color-filled acrylic tag in a fun shape, often for $30 to $37, plus add-on mini charms. Choose Shiloh’s House if you want a $38 acrylic tag that also opens a live online profile when a finder taps it with a phone, with your current contacts and your pet’s medical notes, and an engraved name and phone number as the backup. Neither one is a GPS tracker.
Last updated: November 2026
What is Em & Me Studio known for?
Em & Me Studio is a small studio in Chicago, Illinois, that makes personalized acrylic pet ID tags by hand. Its FAQ says its dog tags are “proudly handcrafted in Chicago Illinois,” and its product pages show a banner reading “24,449+ Sales on Etsy,” which tells you the brand built much of its following on Etsy before and alongside its own shop.
What sets Em & Me apart is design. The Personalized Pet Tags collection reads like a menu of personality: a Ouija Planchette, a Disco Ball, a Sheriff Star, a Ravioli Pasta, a Hot Dog, a Cheese wedge, a Lemon Wedge, a Seashell, a Princess Crown, a Jack-O-Lantern and many more, in colors such as glitter, transparent, opaque and glow-in-the-dark on selected designs. The store also sells seasonal mini charms, Halloween stir sticks, party supplies and plant items, and it runs a blog called The Ampersand covering “pets, plants and parties,” with recent posts on ID tags for indoor cats and multi-cat homes.
Shiloh’s House (that is us, so weigh our view accordingly) also makes personalized acrylic tags, but every one is a smart tag. The front is laser engraved with your pet’s name and phone number. The back says “Tap Phone Here” and holds an NFC chip that opens your pet’s live profile in the free Lohji app. We offer 35 designs.
So the two brands share a material and a love of color, and they part ways on what the tag does after someone picks up your pet. Why that matters: the same ASPCA study found that a tag or microchip was the main way 15% of recovered dogs got home, and very few recovered cats in the survey came home that way. We collect more numbers like these in our lost pet statistics guide.

How do Em & Me and Shiloh’s House tags compare side by side?
Here is the head-to-head, as of November 2026, from each brand’s site. Em & Me details come from its collection page, product pages, FAQ, refund policy and shipping policy. Shiloh’s House details come from our own product information.
| Feature | Em & Me Studio | Shiloh’s House |
|---|---|---|
| Price for one personalized tag | $30 (Tiny Tags) to $39 (Lucy Heart); Clifford large tags $49 to $50 | $38, one-time, no subscription |
| Material | Laser cut acrylic, engraving filled with enamel paint | Premium acrylic, waterproof, scratch-resistant, UV-stable |
| Front engraving | Varies by design; many fit a name and two phone numbers, some put contacts on the back | Laser engraved name and phone number |
| Smart or NFC | No | Yes, “Tap Phone Here” NFC back, no battery |
| App | None | Free Lohji app to manage contacts and medical notes |
| Add-on charms | One seasonal mini included with most personalized tags; extra minis about $4 to $6 | Not offered |
| Returns on personalized items | Not returnable unless damaged or defective; FAQ says it tries to address custom-tag issues within 30 days | 30-day returns |
| Made where | Handcrafted in Chicago, Illinois | Made in the USA |
| Shipping | About 2 weeks of processing (FAQ says 10 to 15 business days); free US standard shipping on orders of $60 or more | See our shop page for current shipping options |
Prices and policies change, so check both sites before you order.
How do Em & Me and Shiloh’s House tags compare on price?
On sticker price, Em & Me has more ways to spend less. Its Tiny Tags line starts at $30, the Minimal Small Circle is $32, and most standard shapes we checked sit between $35 and $37. The Lucy Heart is $39. The Clifford Series, built for big dogs with thicker acrylic and a heavy-duty flat split ring, runs $49 to $50. A two-tag Best Friends set is $63.
Shiloh’s House has one price, $38, for every design, and that includes the NFC chip and the app profile. There is no subscription and no battery to replace.
The table below shows a few real-world baskets. The totals are our own simple math from each brand’s listed prices, before tax and shipping.
| What you buy | Em & Me Studio | Shiloh’s House |
|---|---|---|
| One tag for a cat or tiny dog | $30 (Tiny Tags, pets 10 lb or less) | $38 |
| One standard tag | $35 to $37 | $38 |
| One large-dog tag | $49 to $50 (Clifford) | $38 |
| Standard tag plus a $6 Needs Meds Mini | $41 to $43 (our math) | $38 (medical notes live in the profile) |
Which tag is better if your pet gets lost?

This is the question that matters most, so it is worth walking through what a stranger actually sees and does with each tag in hand.
What a finder gets from an Em & Me tag
An Em & Me tag is a classic visual ID tag, done with style. The text is engraved into the acrylic and filled with color, which the brand says is for “easy, long lasting, readability.” Depending on the design, you can fit a name and up to two phone numbers, or a name, one short line and one number. The Lucy Heart keeps the name on the front in script and puts up to two short lines and two phone numbers on the back. Tiny Tags allow a six-letter name on the front and two back lines of 12 characters each.
The strength here is simplicity. Anyone can read a phone number. No phone feature, no signal and no app is needed. Em & Me’s own buying guide makes the same point, saying a visible phone number is essential and that smart tags work best “as long as the tag still shows a visible phone number.” We agree with that advice.
The limit is that engraved text is fixed on the day it is made. If you change numbers, the person you list stops answering, or your pet needs a daily medication, the tag cannot say so. Em & Me does sell small add-on minis that help here, such as a Microchipped Mini, a Needs Meds Mini and a Medical Alert Personalized Mini, which hang on the same ring as the main tag.
What a finder gets from a Shiloh’s House tag
A Shiloh’s House tag has the same engraved layer, your pet’s name and phone number on the front. On the back, “Tap Phone Here” invites the finder to tap the tag with a phone. That opens your pet’s live profile, with buttons to call, text or get directions, plus multiple contacts, medical notes and voice notes. You manage all of it in the free Lohji app, so when your number changes or you add a pet sitter, the same tag shows the new details right away.
This is useful in exactly the moments when an engraved line runs out of room: a dog on seizure medication, a cat who must stay indoors, a household where two or three people share pickup duty. It is also why researchers keep stressing current contact details. In the Ohio State shelter study led by Linda Lord, the top reason shelters could not reach the owner of a microchipped pet was an incorrect or disconnected phone number.
Where each one falls short
Not every finder will tap a tag, and some phones need NFC turned on. That is why our engraved front matters and why we never ask a finder to rely on tech alone. On the other side, a phone number alone gives a finder one path to you, and if that call goes to voicemail, the trail can stop there. We break down these tradeoffs in our NFC vs QR vs engraved tags guide and in microchip vs smart tag.
The fair summary is this. Both tags give a finder a readable phone number. Only the Shiloh’s House tag adds a second, updatable layer. Pair either one with a registered microchip, because a collar can come off and a chip cannot.
Which is more durable?
Both brands use acrylic, and acrylic is light, quiet and rust-free, but it is not metal. Em & Me is clear about this. Its FAQ says its acrylic and enamel are “waterproof and resistant to various weather conditions,” and also that the tags “are not indestructible and may not withstand chewing or scratching.” It adds that the tags are “not puppy chew proof,” that a broken tag may have sharp edges like other plastics, and that the brand cannot be held responsible for chewed tags. Its homepage FAQ says some customers have worn tags for years while others have seen breaks after a few months.
Em & Me offers one durability upgrade: the Clifford Series for big dogs, made with thicker acrylic (the Clifford Ouija is listed at 0.25 inch thick, versus 0.125 inch for its standard tags) and a heavy-duty flat split ring.
Shiloh’s House tags are premium acrylic built to be waterproof, scratch-resistant and UV-stable, with laser engraving on the front. Still, no acrylic tag, ours included, should be treated as a chew toy. If your dog mouths everything, a stamped metal tag or a slide-on collar plate may last longer, and our acrylic vs metal dog tags guide covers that choice.
Where does Em & Me Studio come out ahead?
Em & Me wins on several points, and we want to say so plainly.
- Lower entry prices. Tiny Tags at $30 and the Minimal Small Circle at $32 cost less than our $38 tag.
- A huge, playful catalog. Food shapes, Halloween designs, glitter, glow-in-the-dark and seasonal drops give you far more looks to choose from than our 35 designs.
- Mini charms. Most personalized tags come with one free seasonal mini, and extra minis cost about $4 to $6, or $20 for a 10-piece Halloween bundle. Minis are made to share the tag’s split ring, so the stack stays small.
- Size range. Tiny Tags for pets 10 pounds or under, standard tags, and Clifford tags for large dogs.
- Custom work. Em & Me will make custom shapes, graphics or colors for an extra fee if you email the studio.
- AirTag-friendly option. The collection lists a slide-on personalized tag that doubles as an AirTag holder.
If your top goal is a cute, lightweight, handmade tag that shows a name and phone number, Em & Me is a strong choice. You can see how it stacks up against other makers in our best acrylic pet tags roundup.
Where does Shiloh’s House come out ahead, and what does neither tag do?
Our tag is built for the moment your pet is found. A finder can tap the back with a phone and reach a live profile with call, text and directions, more than one contact, medical notes and voice notes. You keep that profile current in the free Lohji app, with no subscription, and the chip needs no battery. The engraved name and phone number stay on the front as a backup, and the tag is made in the USA for $38, the same price for every design. You also get 30-day returns.
What neither brand does is track location. Neither tag has GPS, so neither can show you where your pet is on a map. If your dog is a known escape artist or you hike off leash, a GPS collar is the right extra tool, with the tradeoff of charging and usually a monthly plan. An ID tag of either kind helps once someone has your pet in hand.
“The chip is only as good as my ability as a pet owner to keep my information up to date in the registry.”
Linda Lord, lead author and assistant professor of veterinary preventive medicine, Ohio State University (Ohio State News, 2010)
Lord was talking about microchips, but the same rule applies to any ID. In Lohji, the free Shiloh’s House app, you keep the pet profile that a Shiloh’s House smart tag opens when a finder taps it, including your contacts, medical notes and a voice message, and you can edit it whenever life changes. The app also turns your pet’s photo into a cartoon character, a Lohji, for stickers, wallpapers, collector cards and slideshows. Get it free on the App Store or Google Play.
Want another head-to-head? Our Red Dingo vs Shiloh’s House comparison looks at a metal-tag brand.
A cute acrylic tag that also taps to your phone
Shiloh’s House smart tags pair a laser-engraved name and number with an NFC profile you update in the free Lohji app. $38 one-time, no subscription, made in the USA.
Which tag should you choose?
It comes down to what you want the tag to do.
- Pick Em & Me Studio if style comes first, you want a tag for under $38, you love mini charms and seasonal swaps, or you have a tiny cat or toy breed that suits the $30 Tiny Tags line.
- Pick Shiloh’s House if you want a finder to reach more than one person, see medical notes, or always get your current number without ordering a new tag.
- Pick a GPS tracker as well if you need to find a pet who is still on the move. No ID tag does that.
Some families use both: a smart tag as the main ID and a decorative tag or mini for fun. If you do, keep the stack light, use one ring, and make sure every phone number on every tag is one you will answer.
Want another head-to-head with an acrylic maker? See Kissamo vs Shiloh’s House, which compares the Vancouver studio’s 6 mm acrylic tags, CAD pricing and Info Charms with our NFC tag.
Frequently asked questions
Are Em & Me Studio pet tags good?
For a decorative, readable ID tag, yes, they have a lot going for them: handmade in Chicago, engraved and color-filled text, many shapes and colors, and a free seasonal mini with most personalized tags. They are standard visual tags, so they do not include NFC, QR or an online profile, and the brand says they are not puppy chew proof.
Where are Em & Me Studio tags made?
Em & Me’s FAQ says its dog tags are handcrafted in Chicago, Illinois. Shiloh’s House tags are also made in the USA.
How long does Em & Me Studio take to ship?
Em & Me’s shipping policy says it usually turns an order around in roughly two weeks, and its FAQ lists 10 to 15 business days of processing for acrylic tags, before carrier transit time. US standard shipping is free on orders of $60 or more.
Can I return a personalized Em & Me tag?
Em & Me’s refund policy says custom or personalized orders cannot be returned unless they arrive damaged or defective, and its FAQ says it tries to address issues with custom tags within the first 30 days. Un-personalized items can be returned if you contact the studio within 7 days of delivery. Shiloh’s House offers 30-day returns.
Do Em & Me tags have a QR code or NFC chip?
No. The Em & Me tags we reviewed are engraved acrylic ID tags without a QR code or NFC chip. Every Shiloh’s House tag has an NFC chip on the back and an engraved name and phone number on the front.
Do either of these tags track my pet’s location?
No. Neither Em & Me Studio nor Shiloh’s House makes a GPS tag. Em & Me lists a slide-on tag that can hold an AirTag, but an AirTag is a separate device, and a GPS collar is the better choice for live tracking. Both of those run on batteries.
Sources
- Personalized Acrylic Pet ID Tags (collection page), Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Frequently Asked Questions, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Custom Pet Tags, Accessories and Party Supplies (homepage FAQ), Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Refund policy, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Shipping policy, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Lucy Heart Personalized Pet Tag, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Ouija Planchette Personalized Pet Tag, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Tiny Tags, Ouija Planchette Personalized Pet Tag, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Clifford, Ouija Planchette Personalized Pet Tag, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Retro Cassette Tape Personalized Pet Tag, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Clifford Series, Big Tags for Big Pets, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Seasonal Minis, Tiny Pet Charms, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Pet Tag Engraving Guide, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Acrylic vs. Metal Pet Tags, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- The Ampersand blog, Em & Me Studio (2026)
- Frequency of Lost Dogs and Cats in the United States and the Methods Used to Locate Them, Emily Weiss, Margaret Slater and Linda Lord, Animals (2012)
- How Many Pets Are Lost? How Many Find Their Way Home? ASPCA Survey Has Answers, ASPCA (2012)
- Ohio State study: Microchips result in high rate of return of shelter animals to owners, Ohio State News (2010)