The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie vs Nom Nom — and Pro Plan vs Royal Canin vs Hill’s: The 2026 Dog Food Face-Off
Shiloh’s House Team
·
·
2 min read
Our 2026 dog food rankings struck a nerve — it’s one of the most-read pieces on The Journal. The follow-up question we keep getting: “Okay, but between the actual companies — who wins?” So here it is: the specific head-to-heads pet parents are searching for, fresh delivery and kibble giants alike. One important note before we start: we sell pet ID tags, not food, so we have no horse in this race — and for any diet change, your vet knows your dog better than any blog does.
The fresh food showdown: The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie vs Nom Nom
All three deliver refrigerated, human-grade meals formulated with veterinary nutritionists, portioned to your dog. The differences are real but subtle:
| The Farmer’s Dog | Ollie | Nom Nom | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Known for | The category leader; simple recipes, slick experience | Most recipe variety, incl. baked options | Pre-portioned packs, science-forward approach |
| Format | Fresh packs, portion by scoop | Fresh trays + baked/dry mix options | Single-meal pouches |
| Rough cost | Scales with dog size — small dogs a few $/day, large dogs $10+/day | Similar range; mixing with baked lowers cost | Similar range; portioning reduces waste |
| Best fit | First-time fresh feeders who want it easy | Picky eaters and budget-flexers | Precise feeders and small dogs |
Honest bottom line: for most dogs the three are closer than their ads suggest. Get quotes from at least two — pricing for your dog’s size and calories is the real differentiator — and transition slowly over a week to avoid stomach upset. Sundays for Dogs deserves a mention as the no-fridge alternative: air-dried, pour-like-kibble, priced between fresh and premium dry.
The kibble giants: Purina Pro Plan vs Royal Canin vs Hill’s Science Diet
Ask a room of veterinarians what they feed their own dogs and these three names dominate — and it’s not marketing. All three run feeding trials, employ board-certified veterinary nutritionists, and do the unglamorous research work most boutique brands skip.
- Purina Pro Plan — the best price-to-research ratio in the industry, with an enormous range including the sensitive-stomach lines vets recommend constantly.
- Royal Canin — the specialist: breed-specific and condition-specific formulas nobody else matches. You pay for that precision.
- Hill’s Science Diet — the vet-clinic staple, strongest in therapeutic and life-stage diets; the safe, boring, excellent choice.
- Blue Buffalo — the ingredient-list champion. Beautiful labels and real quality, though with less published feeding-trial research than the big three.
If budget decides: Pro Plan. If your dog has a specific breed or medical need: Royal Canin or Hill’s, with your vet’s input. If ingredient philosophy matters most to you: Blue Buffalo or a fresh option above.
Fresh vs kibble: the honest answer
There is no study proving fresh food extends lifespan versus quality kibble — anyone claiming certainty is selling something. What’s true: fresh food is more palatable for picky dogs, kibble is dramatically cheaper and more convenient, and the biggest health lever for most dogs isn’t which premium brand you pick — it’s portion control. Whichever way you go, pick a company that does real nutrition science, and change diets gradually.
Fed. Loved. Tagged?
You research their food this hard — give their ID tag the same upgrade. NFC smart tags + the free Lohji™ app, with vaccine and diet notes right in their profile.
